BushcraftOz | The Australian Bushcraft Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Angle testing ...

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
TwoSun TS09 D2 - Factory 100 / 180grit 200 / 800grit 150 / ground 250 @ 22 degrees ...

The TS09 D2 will be the first knife I explore the angle of the bevel with .
Yes , I know . The tighter the angle , the better the edge holding + cutting power ( slices better / easier )
But what are the numbers ?
I just finished my 60 grit testing .. And the results were positive !
So ....... Now I have to test the angle ..
For this I will use a known performance knife ...
And on the guided knife sharpener I put a 20 degree bevel / edge on the knife . We have some results @ 22 degrees to compare to .
Weather has been McNasty here , but the knife is ready hit the rope .
I will tighten the bevel till the edge rolls . Once the edge rolls , testing becomes pointless .


TwoSun TS09 D2 - Factory 100 / 180grit 200 / 800grit 150 / ground 250 @ 22 degrees ... Previous results @ 22 degrees ..

Edge was first hit with 320 grit diamond , then 600 grit diamond , then 1500 grit oxide and finally 5000 grit stone .
Edge was 20 degrees ..
I first detected a roll at 100 slices and at 150 slices the roll was bad enough call fail ! I guess we have a result ! And it's bad !
THis knife is truly disappointing ! ( For alleged D2 ) I guess this is where this story ends for this knife = Not !
Since I cant take it any further ... I guess there is only one thing to do ... A 60 grit grind !
But before that , the next knife is ready to hit the rope @ 20 degrees .

 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Sorry for being Tardy ! A graphics card has thrown me off my game - black screening on me !

Kershaw Highball XL D2 @ 20 degrees ...
Previously :
200 slices @ 22 degrees with a 220 grit wet stone ground edge
300 slices @ 22 degrees with a 60 grit wet ground edge

And now , with a 20 degree edge - started with 320 grit / 600 grit / 1500 grit / 5000 grit ......... 200 slices ...


Yeah , I just find it hard to be impressed with Kershaw .... ( This one )
 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Ok , Ka-Bar Dozier has just left the rope . And the edge did not roll .. As before . the edge just slowly faded away ( Which is what we like )
Previously @ 22 degrees ... The edge would fail at 150 slices .. Which is not so flash for D2 .
Now for this test the angle of the bevel was tightened to 20 degrees .
And this resulted in a two fifty fail . That's two hundred and fifty slices , or a one hundred slice increase for 2 degrees of angle .
Now that's a result with some meaning . This knife will now be given a 18 degree edge !
Video Soon .

 
Last edited:

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
TT @ 20 degrees
Tassie Tiger D2 at 20 degrees ..
Previously at 22 degrees , this knife did 450 slices .
Now at 20 degrees it has rolled the edge at 400 slices ..
A quick wood strop saw the edge slicing again .. So I guess there is some good and bad there .. But the edge rolled , could not sustain 20 degrees .
But the edge stropped back strong , so that's good ?
Video Soon .

 
Last edited:

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Kershaw @ 18 degrees ...
Previously @ 20 degrees the Kershaw did 200 slices
Now at 18 degrees the Kershaw managed some 250 slices ..
That's a 50 slice increase for 2 degrees of angle tightening . Yes , disappointing blade steel !


Next up at 18 degrees is the Ka-Bar Dozier ...
 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Ka-Bar Dozier @ 18 degrees ,,

Alright , we started at 22 degrees for 150 slices
At 20 degrees we got 250 slices and at 18 degrees we have 300 slices .
These are not huge , massive increases like we got with the 60 grit edge .
Im ho humming going to 16 degrees . Just a matter of interest , there will be another round of 60 grit testing with disappointing knives .
And since we now have some data to play with for the Ka-Bar & Kershaw , I will 60 grit both knives for a comparison ..
So I might stop @ 18 degrees and just 60 grit both knives at 18 degrees for some comparison data . ( Which is better - Grit or angle ? or a Combo ? )
The angle has not made these disappointing knives amazing at all ..
I would hazard that a super steel might respond a lot better to angle variation ( ? ) , I guess .

 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Analyzing the Data ....
TwoSun TS09 D2 - Ok for some reason this knife was forming a False Edge .. Maybe because the steel is hard .. My 65HRC file skated over this blade ..
That's the only thing I can think of , the steel is so hard it forms a false edge ! ( ? ) The other TwoSun I was going to test is also hard .. Both knives are disappointing at edge retention .. Maybe because of a false edge ?
So both knives are a spanner in the works .. But both knives have been reground with the 60 grit wheel and will take part in a second round of 60 grit testing .

Kershaw Highball XL D2
A seriously disappointing knife for the money paid .
200 slices @ 22 degrees with a 220 grit wet stone ground edge
300 slices @ 22 degrees with a 60 grit wet ground edge
Whilst decent D2 knives are doing 400+ slices on the rope ... Yeah , 300 slices @ 22 degrees , ok that's a 50% increase over the 220 grit wet stone .
And using the guided knife sharpener , we got to 250 slices at 18 degrees . Not quite reaching the level of performance the 60 grit edge gave us .

Ka-Bar D2
Another seriously disappointing knife ..
This knife previously returned 150 slices at 22 degrees , not matter the method . ( @ 22 degrees ) No I did not try 60 grit !
At 20 degrees we got 250 slices and at 18 degrees we have 300 slices .
Going to 20 degrees gave us a very decent performance boost , but still short of decent D2 . And 18 degrees , whilst really nice at the rope ( slices well ) , we only saw a 50 slice increase to take us to 300 slices .

So I have two knives @ 18 degrees with some recorded performance data , so it might be time to put both knives to the 60 grit wheel and see what happens at the rope .
 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Where did we leave off !
Dozier D2 - 18 degrees - guided knife sharpener edge ! 300 slices ..
Now we have done 18 degrees & a 60 grit edge .... Can you guess ?
So , which is better ? Grit , or angle ? That is the 50c question ( It's a discounted question cos I'm asking it )
Five hundred and fifty slices with the 60 grit @ 18 degrees edge .
That is a 250 slice improvement on the guided knife sharpener edge .
On what I would call a disappointing knife . That 60 grit has really pulled the Dozier's proverbial out of the fire !

 

old4570

Ray Mears
Joined
Aug 27, 2021
Messages
405
Reaction score
321
Kershaw Highball XL @ 18 degrees and 60 grit ..
Previously the edge rolled at 250 ( guided knife sharpener )
With the 18 degree / 60 grit edge it rolled again at 250 slices .. Well , at least it's consistent !
The Kershaw is in my own Humble opinion a OverPriced UnderPerforming Knife .. The one I own ! The one I have tested / over & over again .

 
Top